Q2 2024 Market Commentary

Q2 2024YTD 2024
S&P 5004.28%15.29%
Bloomberg US Agg Bond Index 0.07%-0.71%

The US stock market stumbled at the beginning of the second quarter due to inflation concerns and expectations of fewer rate cuts. However, easing inflation data and the promise of AI propelled the market to new highs by the quarter’s end. 

The economy has begun to exhibit signs of cooling off, as evidenced by significant downward revisions to Q2 GDP growth estimates. Multiple indicators point toward economic softening: rising unemployment, declining PMI Services activity, and increasing delinquencies on consumer debt.

These weakening economic measures serve as a Rorschach test for market participants. Bears interpret the data as a sure sign we’re entering a recession. Bulls see a soft landing that will bring inflation back to the Federal Reserve’s target of 2%. 

My primary concern remains elevated valuations and the prospects of muted future returns in US equities. Investors have plowed into the stock market like never before. Household allocations to stocks have never been higher. Historically, high investor allocations to equities have been a strong predictor of poor future returns. Their predictive power has even surpassed my preferred valuation metrics. 

Weakening Economic Data 

In May, the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow estimate of Q2 GDP growth exceeded 4%. As economic data softened through June, GDPNow dropped its estimate to 2%. While that’s still positive growth, this represents a significant moderation from earlier, more robust projections.

The rising unemployment rate is particularly concerning. After hitting a low of 3.4% in early 2023, the unemployment rate has steadily increased to 4.1%: 

Historically, such increases in unemployment have typically preceded the onset of recessions. When the 3-month moving average of unemployment rises by more than ½ a percent from its 12-month low, the US has always been in a recession: 

Source: Bloomberg, Zerohedge 

Currently, this average is 0.43% above its 12-month low, nearing the recessionary threshold.

The ISM Manufacturing PMI index, which measures US manufacturing activity, has been in negative territory for 19 of the last 20 months. The two previous instances of such prolonged weakness coincided with recessionary periods (1989-’91 and 1981-’83). It seems the economy has been able to shrug off this weakness so far, as manufacturing now accounts for a smaller portion of the US economy. 

Services on the other hand account for nearly 80% of US economic activity. Until recently, the ISM Services PMI index had been in expansionary territory. In June, the index went into contractionary territory. There have only been 4 periods when both the ISM Manufacturing and the ISM Services indices have been in negative territory at the same time: 

  • July 2008 – July ’09 (Recession)
  • -April-May 2020 (Recession)
  • -December 2022
  • -April 2024, Today

Here’s a look at the weakening ISM Services PMI index:

Source: Bloomberg data, @convertbond 

A final weakening economic data point comes from the consumer as there are increasing signs of consumer financial stress. Serious delinquencies, defined by overdue balances of more than 90 days, have been steadily increasing over the past couple of years. While credit card delinquencies have seen the most pronounced increase, both auto loans and mortgages have also experienced upward trends in delinquency rates:

Soft Landing Optimism

Despite weak economic measures, many Wall Street firms believe the economy will achieve a soft landing and avoid a recession. According to Bank of America Securities, “Data has softened, economic surprises are starting to skew negative, and if inflation doesn’t moderate the Fed won’t cut rates – stagflation is back on bears’ lips. But zooming out from the last few quarters reveals that delinquencies, PMI, labor tightness, retail sales, and most other gauges of economic health are simply normalizing from unsustainably high levels. We see healthy, not recessionary, macro trends.”

COVID may have diminished the usefulness of many traditional economic indicators. In late 2022, 100% of economists surveyed by Bloomberg expected a recession in the following year. Since then the economy has been surprisingly resilient with consumer spending leading the way. Increased interest rates, which resulted in an inverted yield curve, were supposed to put the brakes on the economy. In the short run, the economy has surged ahead regardless. 

Federal Reserve policy is said to work with a long and variable lag. It’s possible that traditional recession signals still apply, but their effects are delayed. Consumers and corporations do not appear to be as overextended in their borrowing as they have been in past cycles. Both locked in low rates on long-term debt, which spared them from the initial impacts of rising rates. 

Massive fiscal stimulus has likely been the key factor preventing a recession. The current fiscal deficit is unprecedented outside of war or recession: 

Source: Congressional Budget Office.

Will this fiscal stimulus be enough to avoid a recession? It would be unprecedented for the US to enter a recession with such a large deficit (outside of war). It’s also worth noting that not all economic data are weakening. For instance, TSA data shows demand for air travel is at an all-time high. Heavy truck sales, which typically plummet before a recession, remain at elevated levels. 

At this point, there remains something for everyone in the data. Bears can point to indicators such as rising unemployment that seem to guarantee an impending recession. Bulls can highlight the massive fiscal stimulus and mixed data as evidence of a healthy economic moderation that will facilitate a return to normalcy.

Household Allocation to Equities 

Households are all-in on the stock market. Household allocation to equities is currently at an all-time high: 

Investors’ allocation to equities has been called the single greatest predictor of future stock market returns. The correlation between equity allocation and 10-year future stock market returns is over 90%, a stronger relationship than the correlation between any valuation metric and future returns. Given the current high allocation, future stock market returns are projected to be among the lowest in history.

It is noteworthy that this extreme overallocation to equities coincides with some of the most elevated stock market valuations in history. Investors with significant exposure to the S&P 500 and major U.S. stock market indices should proceed with caution. The long-term outlook for returns, based on these metrics, appears challenging.

A Note on Elections 

With the US election upcoming in November, numerous clients have asked me about its impact on markets. It is natural to speculate on how political outcomes may influence market dynamics. However, empirical evidence suggests that there is no discernible relationship between elections and financial market performance, at least in the United States. The general rule of thumb is not to let politics interfere with your investing policy. 

Here’s a look at annualized investment returns under different presidencies going back to 1969:

Source: Edward Jones 

The subpar returns from 2001-2009 were primarily driven by a stock market that commenced the period at extreme valuation levels as the internet bubble was beginning to unwind. When President Bush’s term concluded in 2009, the global financial crisis was in full swing, and stock market valuations had declined significantly. The political landscape of the period had minimal influence on the poor returns, and it is worth noting that no one predicted the formation and subsequent collapse of the housing bubble when Bush was first elected.

Similarly, during President Nixon’s term from 1969-1974, the stock market began at extremely elevated levels as the Nifty Fifty stocks were experiencing rapid appreciation. With the oil crisis and economic recession, the market concluded the period at some of the lowest valuation levels in history by 1974.

The impact of politics on markets often defies conventional wisdom. President Biden assumed office promoting a green agenda and renewable energy, largely perceived as antagonistic to traditional energy sectors such as oil and gas. Yet, the energy sector has been the best-performing segment of the market since Biden took office. Conversely, President Trump was (and is) viewed as an ally to the oil and gas industry, with “Drill baby, drill” as one of his slogans. However, the energy sector lost over 50% of its value during his term in office. While COVID certainly played a role in depressing oil prices toward the end of his presidency, it is worth noting that the margins and profitability of energy companies were substantially lower during his term in office than during Biden’s tenure. This underscores the point that there are forces far more influential than politics driving investment returns. To the extent that politics impact markets, it often manifests in unexpected ways.

Conclusion

As we enter Q3, the debate between a soft landing and recession continues. In response to weakening economic data and moderating inflation, markets are now anticipating the Federal Reserve’s first rate cut in September.

Given record-high equity allocations and elevated valuations, I believe the most prudent path forward is to exercise caution with US equities and patiently await better future opportunities. 

Scott Caufield, CFA, CPA 

7/12/2024

Similar Posts